Fruits of warrantless arrest lead panel to vote for new trial
All evidence resulting from a warrantless arrest has been thrown out and a new trial ordered for a Brooklyn criminal defendant. The Appellate Division, 2nd Department has ruled that the police and lower court erred in the prosecution of a man whose rights were violated when he was arrested sans a warrant.
A Brooklyn jury found Derrick Riffas guilty of second degree murder after a 2009 trial in Brooklyn’s criminal court. To secure his arrest, police came to Riffas’ home at 6:50 a.m. Riffas came to the door partially clothed and apparently “half asleep,” the court noted. He opened the door halfway, and upon realizing that it was the police, he attempted to close the door but was prevented by a detective’s arm intentionally jamming the door.
Riffas did not voluntarily cross the threshold of his apartment to exit, but was pulled into the outside hallway by the police and subsequently arrested. Court records show that police officers pushed Riffas’ door in, came into his home and physically removed him.