City retains teen’s brain, court reduces family award
A family was awarded $1 million for the pain and suffering they endured after discovering that their son’s brain was held by the Staten Island Medical Examiner without notification. The Appellate Division, Second Department, sitting in Brooklyn Heights, reduced the award to $600,000 on Wednesday.
On a class trip to the Medical Examiner’s Office a teen noticed a brain suspended in formaldehyde. This isn’t an unexpected visual at the morgue, except that this brain was labeled as belonging to the teen’s friend, Jesse Shipley, who died in a car crash.
Upon learning that their son’s organ was held without any notification or permission, Andre and Korisha Shipley, Jesse’s parents, sued the city asserting that the family was denied the right of sepulcher or the right to choose the final disposition of a dead body.